-
4
May
Anthony Beaumont analyses the independent school influence in shaping football as we know it.
Originally, association football was codified in the 1860s. It was a game that was predominately played in the south, by former Public School pupils and Oxbridge graduates. But the game as we see it seems far from such humble beginnings. Football has been globalised. It has become a universal commodity, with omnipotent potential and the plaything for the uber-rich. Yet as it has blossomed and snow-balled, slowly the Independent School influence subsided and now seems non-existent. Here is a list of the main players and authorities who have helped to grow and give stimulus to the game we now know.
The Old Etonians
Founded by Lord Kinnaird (see later), the Old Etonians were the last amateur side to win the FA Cup. Indeed many of the earliest recipients of ‘the Cup’ were made up of men who shared the same Alma Mater and came from an Independent School background. Many members of that side, went on to represent England, including Arthur Dunn (2 caps) and Robert Gosling (5 caps). Considering the illustrious history and renowned status of the FA Cup, it seems unbelievable that the likes of the Old Etonians, Wanderers and Old Carthusians could count themselves equals to winners such as Arsenal and Manchester United.
The Wanderers
Initially Forest FC was partially founded by W.C. Alcock, an old Harrovian. It was Alcock who suggested that a Challenge Cup should be created as a tournament for Association teams to contest. You could say that the FA Cup originally began as an insular competition for Independent Schools alumni. The Wanderers were comprised of many ex-Public School boys, like Alcock. Again they can count themselves as a successful FA Cup side, winning the competition a staggering five times. The Wanderers were a celebrated side in the history of the World’s oldest competition and were key members in making the competition as prominent as it is today.
Old Carthusians
Mainly comprised Charterhouse alumni, the Old Carthusians won the FA Cup in 1881. Percy Melmoth Walters and his brother Arthur, played for England on 13 and 9 occasions respectively, amongst many others who also represented their country while Old Carthusian players.
Clapham Rovers
Clapham Rovers won the FA Cup in 1880. They can count former Westminster Pupil, Norman Bailey as one of their greatest players, who represented England on 19 occasions.
Lord Kinnaird
Perhaps the greatest Independent School influence on football, Arthur Kinnaird won the FA Cup 5 times, with both the Old Etonians and the Wanderers. He was known as the toughest tackler of his day and was known to have played every position on the pitch during his illustrious career, reaching 9 FA Cup Finals. He was FA president for 33 years and died months after opening Wembley Stadium.
David Elleray
David Elleray is a former Premier League referee, who officiated 13 games at Wembley Stadium. Even more remarkably, he did so whilst a being a Master, notably at Harrow. He officiated in 78 international matches. He is now chairman of the Independent School’s Football Association. In the modern professional game, there is a surprising, if not un-lauded, independent school influence:
Frank Lampard (Chelsea) attended Brentwood school and played in the 1993-94 Boodle & Dunthorne Isfa cup. Nedum Onuoha (Manchester City, currently on loan at Sunderland) attended Hulme grammar school (Oldham). Victor Moses (Wigan athletic) was born in Nigeria but moved to England at the age of 11 after his parents were murdered. He attended Whitfift School where he was a member of their side that won the Isfa u14 schools cup in 2005. James Beattie (Blackpool) was a pupil at Qegs Blackburn and played for the Isfa under-16 and North under-18 teams in season 1993-94. Conor Henderson (Arsenal) was a pupil at Colfe’s school. Fraser Forster (Newcastle united, currently on loan at Celtic) is a former pupil of RGS Newcastle who also played for the Isfa u16 representative team. Chris Porter (Derby County) has proved that it is possible to make a career in football after staying at school until 18 to complete ‘A’ levels. He studied at Qegs Blackburn for whom he scored the winning goal against Brentwood school in the 2001 boodle & Dunthorne Isfa cup final. Neil Mellor (Preston North End, currently on loan to Sheffield Wednesday) is a former pupil of St. Bede’s college in Manchester. Neil Harris (Millwall) is a former pupil at Brentwood school. Frank Fielding (Blackburn rovers, currently on loan at Derby County) kept goal for Qegs Blackburn in the 2004 Boodles Isfa cup final. Jordan Spence (West Ham United, currently on loan at Bristol City) was a pupil at Chigwell school. Tom Kilbey (Portsmouth) was educated at Forest school and played for the Isfa u16 representative of 8. Oliver gill (Manchester United) attended Manchester grammar school, for whom he appeared in the 2008-09 boodles Isfa cup. Jimmy Armfield of Arnold school went on to play his entire career at Blackpool, appearing 569 times, and to play 43 times for England, on several occasions as captain. George Eastham, Arnold school, who won 19 England caps whilst a player with Arsenal. Stewart Robson left Brentwood school at 16 and in 1982 made his debut in Arsenal’s first team at the age of 17. Quinton Fortune attended Forest school and appeared for them in the first Boodle & Dunthorne Isfa Cup final.
Perhaps history is turning full circle. The historic influence of independent schools on professional football has a quieter, but nonetheless palpable, influence on the modern game. Football has now become a middle-class game. Originally a medieval pass-time, whole villages would engage in kicking something of a spherical nature. It was brutal and unlike the sophistication of the modern day. The independent schools codified the game as we know it, it could be seen as the Independent school’s gift to the working class. During the 20th century, the top players were from working class backgrounds. But today, many Independent school graduates are engaging at the highest level. With ever-rising ticket prices, super-rich owners and the pull to all classes of high wages, Football is becoming middle-class. Football is the Independent School gift, but it might be making a comeback on the playing side of the game. While independent schools were heavyweights in the 19th century, their effect is no more than a ripple now.
none




An unpopular view perhaps? But then, I’ve been incensed by England lately, and there have been three real reasons.






it’s Man City looking for him. Trade deal with Arsenal would still mean that Barcelona would have to add cash to the deal. Other smaller buyers would be willing to offer ranging from ?25m~?35m.
finalised the “Big Four”, who dominated the top four positions of the Premiership for the latter half of the decade. No other clubs were given a look-in. Man. City, as soon as they were bought, were rumored to be able to upset this imbalance that had formed at the top of British football.
Chelsea fans can be heard singing in the streets, all around premiership fever is in the air. Whilst the rest of the British population is worrying about the election, die-hard fans are happily reveling by the side of the road singing the Chelsea anthem.